Just another gadget?
The Case for Lasers
By Kathy Jackson
Let me confess my biases right up front: I love lasers, for a bunch of
different reasons. Though I've handled and fired several other brands,
most of my experience has been with the
Crimson Trace brand so if there's anything brand-specific below,
assume I'm talking about Crimson Trace
brand Lasergrips.
What is a laser?
The technical answer is that a laser is an optical source that uses "Light
Amplification by the Stimulated
Emission of Radiation." That's the official
acronym for the thing. There's a pretty good article over on
Wikipedia if you want to learn more technical details about how
lasers emit light and about all the different gadgets in which lasers
are used.
In the firearms world, when someone refers to a laser, they are talking
about an alternative sighting device, similar to a laser pointer, which
lets the user know when the gun is lined up properly by putting a brightly-colored
dot right where the bullet will land if the trigger is pulled at that
moment.
There are many different types of laser aiming devices available for different
types of firearms, and the lasers can be mounted on your firearm in different
ways. Each of the various types has its own advantages and disadvantages.
Rifle- and shotgun-mounted lasers are beyond the scope of this article,
and I am frankly not qualified to discuss them intelligently.
For pistol-mounted lasers, there are three basic configurations:
- Rail-Mounted Lasers. Rail-mounted lasers
are available from multiple manufacturers. They attach just underneath
the barrel of a handgun which is equipped with built-in rails. They cannot
be used with firearms which are not designed for them. They do not affect
either the grip size or shape, or alter function of the gun in any way,
but they can have a significant effect on the gun's weight and balance.
Rail-mounted lasers are the most easily-installed type of laser sight.
However, those with short fingers may find that the control switch is
too far forward for easy access, and most shooters will discover that
reaching forward to activate the control switch slows down the shot. It
can be difficult to find a holster designed to fit a specific laser, so
installing a rail-mounted laser is not preferred for a carry gun.
- Guide Rod Lasers. Manufactured by the
LaserMax Corporation, guide rod
lasers replace the handgun's factory guide rod with an aftermarket laser
unit, which fills the normal function of the guide rod while it also functions
as a laser sight. As with the rail-mounted lasers, guide rod lasers are
activated by the trigger finger just before firing, and this can slow
the shooter down. Guide rod lasers do not change the balance or weight
of the pistol, and do not alter the exterior of the pistol in any significant
way. They do not require specially-fitted holsters.
- Laser Grips. These laser aiming devices,
primarily produced by the Crimson Trace
Corporations, are built right into specially-designed plastic
or rubberized grips, and are activated by a pressure-sensitive pad somewhere
on the grip itself. With the exception of a "clamshell" type addition
for popular Glock firearms, they are not available for firearms which
do not have replaceable grips. Laser grips do alter the feel of the gun
in your hand, and do not yet come in a variety of sizes to suit smaller
or larger hands than the average. Some models affect the shape of the
firearm enough to require a specially-designed holster, but most do not.
The pressure-activated Lasergrips are the most intuitive and fastest lasers
to operate for most people.
Why do I love lasers? Let me count the ways ...
- They are light-years faster in the dark than any other sighting
system. People who say "just get night sights" instead of a
laser simply haven't compared the two sighting systems side by side when
shooting under stress and on a timer. If they had, they'd prefer lasers,
hands down.
- They are far easier on multiple targets in the dark. Transitioning
from one target to another to another is very simple and very fluid. There's
no added time to settle down on each target -- just bang and go.
- On moving targets, especially on moving targets in the dark, they
are faster and easier than any other system. Singles or multiples, if
the target is moving, it's just flat out easier with a laser. Again, no
comparison is possible. Very few people have had opportunity to shoot
movers in the dark, but take my word on this one: if you want to hit something
that is moving, and if lighting conditions are less than optimal, the
laser is absolutely the way to go.
- Under stress, lasers let you do what you instinctively want to do:
keep your eyes on the threat.
- You can stay nearly 100% behind cover while using a laser and be
assured of getting your hits.
- You can shoot from all kinds of contorted, awkward positions using
irregularly-shaped cover (like real life objects rather than range equipment)
and still hit what you want to hit.
- In all but brightest daylight, lasers are faster and easier on moving
targets. They're also incredibly fast and intuitive when you and the target
are both moving.
- Laser grips work very well for instructional demonstrations.
When you demonstrate a technique, the laser makes it very easy for students
to see exactly what you are doing -- for instance, in showing people the
proper follow through on multiple targets, they can simply watch how the
laser moves from target to target while you explain the technique.
Explaining trigger squeeze, students can see how an improper yank jerks
the dot off center and they can see how a smooth trigger pull keeps the
sights on target. You can also use the laser to demonstrate what a "wobble
zone" is and how accepting that "wobble zone" can actually
improve their performance.
- Instructors can use also use lasers to assist with student diagnostics.
It is very easy to see what the student is doing with a laser-equipped
gun. You can watch the dot to see if they're jerking it off-center at
the last second. You can see how much muzzle movement the student is getting
during move-and-shoot drills.
- A laser is also a good range safety tool because you can use it
to help teach muzzle awareness. For instance, when demonstrating a proper
low ready position, you can use a laser-equipped dummy gun to show where
the bullet would strike when the gun is held incorrectly. You can show
the "circle of safety" when the gun is held correctly, and most
students will immediately grasp the point. If you have someone reholstering
incorrectly, you can use a laser-equipped dummy gun to show why the technique
they were using was dangerous and to illustrate which body part was at
risk.
Criticisms and Myths
Of course, there are standard criticisms and myths about the laser that
we've all heard. Here are my answers to those.
"Lasers give away your position." Not if you have
properly trained to use them. With CT grips, for instance, it is very
simple to train yourself to relax your grip when the gun isn't on target,
thus shutting off the light. Other brands have levers or buttons that
must be flicked on; in either case, the proper moment to activate the
laser is not until you are sure of your target and are raising the gun
to fire.
"You can't always see that dot in all lighting conditions."
That's true -- the laser will not always be visible to you in all circumstances.
This is one reason why it is so important to
practice with a laser rather than simply hanging it on your gun
and expecting it to do all the work. You will need to learn what you can
expect from your laser in order to use it to best advantage, and you absolutely,
positively must also continue to practice shooting with your regular
sights. Lasers are an addition to regular sights, not a replacement
for them.
"Batteries die." Yeah, so what? Dead batteries don't
destroy your normal sighting system and it'll still be there. You'll be
no worse off if your batteries die than you would be without having the
laser in the first place, and considerably better off if your batteries
don't die. Furthermore, most people who rely on this equipment to save
their lives also manage to maintain it -- keeping the carry ammo fresh,
keeping the gun clean and properly lubricated, keeping the holster in
good repair. The laser batteries simply become one more minor item on
your firearms maintenance checklist.
Some tips for managing battery life:
- Rather than allowing your carry gun's laser batteries
to drain during practice, consider keeping two sets of batteries on hand
at all times: one set for practice, and the other for carry. Swap the
batteries out when you get to the range for practice, and replace the unused
batteries when you leave the range.
- Check battery life whenever you clean your firearm.
- Replace your carry batteries twice a year, at the same
time you set your clocks ahead or back for Daylight Savings Time (and
remember to replace the batteries in your smoke alarms at the same
time!)
"The bad guy will see the red dot on his chest and surrender immediately."
The problem with this myth is that it's a little bit true, which means
that if you rely upon it, you could end up a little bit dead. The truth
is that you have absolutely no way of knowing whether your attacker will
even notice that red dot. If he does notice it, his response is not within
your power to control. He might surrender meekly. Then again, he might just
lunge for you in a rage. In either case, you should never point your firearm
at anyone whom you are not emotionally and legally prepared to shoot (see
the AOJ article). The thing to remember is that the laser is really an
aiming device, not an intimidation tool. That little red dot
should only appear on his chest during the split second it will take you to aim and
pull the trigger.
"Lasers blind people." It is true that some laser
devices can blind people. It is most emphatically not true that
firearm lasers can do so. The lasers designed for use with a firearm fall
into the same classification as standard laser pointers used at board
meetings for over 20 years, devices which have never been implicated in
any eye injuries. Of course, it is a very bad idea to point your firearm-mounted
laser at your eyeball, but that is because in order to you do so, you would be violating
one of the Four Rules of Gun Safety.
"You don't have to train to use the laser." Absolutely
false. It takes time to learn to intuit when the laser will work best
and when the iron sights will work best, and to train yourself to automatically
try the better option first in all lighting conditions. Let me add here
that some lighting conditions aren't great for the laser. That's not a
big deal; transitioning back to iron sights or to point-shoot takes very,
very little time once you've trained on such transitions. But these transitions
will be slow until you have trained to use them, so don't fool yourself.
You cannot use lasers to their best advantage until you have trained yourself
to use them.
"Someone with a laser will always outshoot someone without one."
Moderately false. If you have two equally-trained shooters, one with a
laser and one without, and they are both equally familiar with their own
equipment, the one with the laser will usually perform better and faster,
depending upon the situation. But the existence of the laser does not
turn a marginal shooter into a good one. It doesn't replace trigger control
and it doesn't teach you how to run the gun quickly and smoothly. It doesn't
do anything except enable you to line up the gun faster than you yourself
would otherwise be able to do -- after you've trained yourself to use
the laser.
Bottom line? I love lasers and think they are excellent equipment for
shooters who are willing to take the time to learn how to use them to
best advantage. They don't replace regular sights and they don't solve
every problem. But the things they do, they do better than any other sighting
option out there.